[sustran] "The Future Intelligent Transport Systems initiative" - one more short-sighted interest-fed government-industry boondoggle

[Eric Britton]

PS: Harsh criticism as this may seem, my goal here is a very positive one. Read
on.

 

Boondoggle: Hate to say it John but to my mind this is but one more
short-sighted interest-fed government-industry boondoggle: in short the winners
are once again circling their wagons and gaily divvying up the accumulating
spoils while the planet and the well being of ordinary people continue to come
under grave attack every day as the establishment continues in all impunity to
ignore the real bottom line. Which believe me is not “intelligent” transport
systems.

 

Oops: The fact that such a program is further interest-driven by members of the
academic community, who to my mind should have a far deeper understanding of the
gravity of the situation we face in this sector and its many components and
spin-offs, is, in its own way, quite grave.  Dear academic colleagues. May I
respectfully ask that you step back from this kind of thing until we have made
at least some palpable progress on the terrible matters at hand.  Your
intellect, skills and energy are much needed on far more important things.

 

Syndrome: This is part of a larger syndrome to which we have collectively
subscribed without quite realizing it. Namely, our sector has fallen victim to
an egregious Cartesian tendency to parcelize the whole into many bits and pieces
beyond the limits of any common sense (just look at the organigram of any
ministry of transport to see how that works) and then sub-optimize this and that
with gay abandon. Thus we have roads and streets that have been optimized
through construction and yes! electronics for speed and throughput, when the
communities around them have quite a different set of requirements. And what
could be a better indication of this than our exchanges of yesterday on the
subject of the New York times article  'Delays mire U.S. road project in Aceh '
look at Robert Cowherd’s telling comments on this in the morning mails here.
(And BTW, can anyone think of a good name for this syndrome?)

 

Refocus: The fact is that we are now at a fork in the road, and if there is any
one thing that can help us make a choice as to where we are now going to invest
our energies and brilliance, it is to the following simple question which to my
mind should stand first in line every time any public authority is going to use
our hard earned taxpayer money (it’s ours, not theirs) to fund stuff that is
going to shape the future. “What can be done via this line of action (in their
case ITS) so that we can put those technologies to use in THE NEXT TWO TO THREE
YEARS TO GET VISIBLE RESULTS AND PATTERNS OF POLICY AND PRACTICE THAT CAN BE
REPLCIATED BROADLY AND AT LOW COST WORLD WIDE.  And if your program is not
structured to respond to this usefully, then out it goes. We can look at the
long term when we have some breathing space. But this is not the situation in
October 2006 and will not be surly for the remainder of this decade.

 

So off you go Department for Transport, Department of Trade and Industry and the
Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council and all your good friends
from industry: redline your mandate along these lines and you have something
really useful there.  Keep us informed. We too are part of the solution. Work
with us on it. 

 

Eric Britton

 

PS2. Dear colleagues. Am I horribly wrong in this? If so it would not be the
first time. So let me put it in front of our various peer groups here so that we
can get different views on this. 

 

 

 

 

A radical new approach to funding highly innovative and wide ranging

research into key long term transport issues was announced yesterday by 

Minister for Transport Stephen Ladyman and Lord Sainsbury, DTI Minister 

for Science and Innovation, at the Intelligent Transport Systems World 

Congress in London.

 

 

The new approach to research is expected to result in far greater 

Advances than simply awarding funding to a single organisation. It will allow a 

small number of consortia with wide ranging expertise to work in 

collaboration to tackle some of the major transport challenges we face 

over the next decade.

 

 

The Department for Transport, Department of Trade and Industry and the

Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council will jointly provide 

£9 million of funding, with a further £3 million expected from industry 

itself.

 

The Future Intelligent Transport Systems initiative is intended to

stimulate new ideas, concepts, products or services that will:

 

    * Further improve safety on our roads by reducing collisions,

 casualties and deaths;

 

    * Result in better, more reliable, accessible and safer public

 transport services;

 

    * Lead to even greater efficiency in the road freight industry;

 

    * Improve road network management; and,

 

    * Provide better travel information, allowing travellers to make

 informed choices on how and when to travel.

 

Further details can be found within the call for Expressions of 

Interest to participate, which can be found at: 

<http://www.dti.gov.uk/innovation/tech-priorities-uk/innovation_platforms/page33
795.htmlhttp://www.dti.gov.uk/innovation/tech-priorities-uk/innovation_platforms
/page33795.html 

 

 

Jon Maybury

Innovation Platform Manager

 

Intelligent Transport Systems

Department of Trade and Industry

Office of Science and Innovation (OSI)

151 Buckingham Palace Road,

London SW1W 9SS

 

Tel: 0207 215 1196

Mobile: 07810 558891

Home Office: 01252 819610

Email: <mailto:jon.maybury at dti.gsi.gov.ukjon.maybury@dti.gsi.gov.uk

Email (on the move): 

<mailto:jmaybury1 at googlemail.comjmaybury1@googlemail.com

 

Web: <http://www.dti.gov.uk/innovation/tech-priorities-uk/innovation_platfor

ms/index.htmlhttp://www.dti.gov.uk/innovation/tech-priorities-uk/innov

ation_platforms/index.html

 

 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://list.jca.apc.org/public/sustran-discuss/attachments/20061010/a5305b64/attachment.html