[sustran] Re: CNG buses in Punjab

[Alan Howes]

I assume you want replies by the list, Hassan?
 
I am not an expert in bus engineering, more in operations.  But I would say to be careful in what you are comparing CNG with.  Don't just compare with "Existing" (which I rather think is what was done in Delhi).  In particular, look at the best of Diesel engine technology (e.g. Euro 5), which may well give 95% of the benefits of CNG but at a much lower cost and without some of the problems.
 
Regards, Alan  (from Mumbai)
 
-- 
Alan Howes
Associate Transport Planner
Colin Buchanan
4 St Colme Street, Edinburgh, EH3 6AA
Tel:       +44 131 226 4693
Mobile:  +44 7952 464335
email:  alan.howes at cbuchanan.co.uk <mailto:alan.howes at cbuchanan.co.uk> 

www: http:/www.cbuchanan.co.uk/


________________________________

From: sustran-discuss-bounces+alan.howes=cbuchanan.co.uk at list.jca.apc.org on behalf of Hassaan Ghazali
Sent: Fri 25/08/2006 12:19
To: sustran-discuss at list.jca.apc.org
Subject: [sustran] CNG buses in Punjab



*Apologies for cross-postings*

Friends, 

The Government of the Punjab is seriously considering the shift to CNG in buses which ply the streets of large cities in the province. In this regard, I need some straightforward and rather urgent advice as the matter has reached a critical stage in the decision making process. There is general consensus on the economic benefits and energy security CNG use provides but there are still uncertainties regarding the finer points of engine compatibility, tariffs, fuel efficiency and environmental effects. The summary report moved by the transport department is terse which makes us believe that there is definitely some analytical work to be done, especially on the infrastructure deficit, costs involved and social impact.   

To a large extent, the government is inspired by the Delhi experience and there are concerns about the current state of the environment there and whether any recent third party evaluation of the intervention in Delhi has taken place? If you could advise on this, or comment on whether you consider the move to CNG to have helped Delhi's urban sphere, it would enable us to make an informed decision. 

Thanking you in advance, 
 
Hassaan Ghazali

-- 
Legal and Institutional Reform Specialist (Acting)
Urban Sector Policy and Management Unit (The Urban Unit)  
Planning and Development Department, 
Government of the Punjab 

A: 4-B Lytton Road, Lahore
T: (+92 42) 921 3579-84 Ext.116
M:(+92 345) 455 6016
F: (+92 42) 921 3585
Skype:halgazel
http://hghazali.googlepages.com <http://hghazali.googlepages.com/>  

........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
DISCLAIMER

This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to which they are addressed. Unless you are the named addressee, or authorised to receive it for the addressee, you may not copy or use it, or disclose it to anyone else. If you have received this email in error please contact the sender by replying to this email.

Any views expressed by an individual within this email which do not constitute or record professional advice relating to the business of Colin Buchanan, do not necessarily reflect the views of the company. Any professional advice or opinion contained within this email is subject to our terms and conditions of business.

We have taken precautions to minimise the risk of transmitting software viruses. We do not accept liability for any loss or damage caused by software viruses.


-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://list.jca.apc.org/public/sustran-discuss/attachments/20060825/50ef7865/attachment.html